Market making is a race against time
A market maker’s job is to keep their buy and sell prices close to the real market price at all times. When the real price moves, the market maker has to update their price fast. If they are too slow, someone else can trade against their old price and make an easy profit at the market maker’s expense. This is sometimes called getting picked off. On most exchanges this race is fair, because everyone pays for the same kind of fast connection and everyone competes on roughly equal terms. On Solana, the race is tilted against the market maker.Why Solana makes this harder
Most on-chain orderbooks still use one shared account to hold the whole order book. Every market maker who wants to change a price has to update that same account. When the market moves fast, that becomes a problem. If a hundred market makers all try to update their prices in the same moment, only one of them can go first. Everyone else has to wait, pay higher fees to try to go first, or get stuck with an old price. This is often called “write-lock contention”: everyone is fighting to write to the same account, and only one write per account can happen per slot. A bot watching the market can trade against that old price before the market maker has a chance to fix it.How the market reacted: propAMMs
To avoid this problem, several teams built a different kind of program, often called a propAMM. Instead of posting many individual orders, a propAMM uses a single pricing formula and updates just a few numbers whenever the market moves. This made price updates fast and cheap, and today the majority of all spot trading on Solana flows through this kind of program. This approach solves the speed problem, but it creates new ones.- Each one is a black box. A propAMM is a single closed program run by one team. Nobody outside that team can see what is actually happening inside it or why it quotes the price it does. That one team controls everything about how the pool behaves, and when you trade through an app like Jupiter, you are not trading against one shared, visible market. You are being routed across many of these separate black boxes, stitched together behind the scenes.
- The price you see is not always the price you get. An aggregator quotes a propAMM by simulating a trade against its state at that moment, but the pool’s price is set entirely by its own closed logic, with nothing stopping it from changing before your trade actually settles. Studies of propAMM pricing have found cases where a pool quotes an attractive price in the window aggregators sample from, then settles trades at a worse one once they land, a pattern distinct from the market simply moving. Because the logic is closed, neither a trader nor an aggregator can tell the two apart from the outside.
- The pricing logic is hidden. The same closed code that quotes your price also decides how much of your order gets filled. There is no way for you or an aggregator to check the math.
- Only a few teams can run one. Building a propAMM means writing a custom Solana program, hiring engineers who know how to make it fast, and solving hard problems around getting transactions to land on time. This is expensive, so only a small number of well funded teams can do it. Everyone else is locked out.
- Only that one team ever gets to benefit. Because a propAMM is one closed program run by one operator, no other market maker can plug into it and quote alongside it. The speed and tight pricing it achieves stay locked inside that one team, instead of being something any market maker who wants to compete can use.

